Review of ADHD for Smart Ass Women: How to Fall in Love with Your… by Tracy Otsuka
I picked up ADHD for Smart Ass Women by Tracy Otsuka with hopeful curiosity, intrigued by the title that promised a combination of sass and wisdom. As someone who navigates life with ADHD, I was eager to find a voice that might resonate with me—or at least offer some useful insights into the tangled web of neurodiversity in women. However, what unfolded was a mixed bag of anecdotes and advice that felt both relatable and frustrating in equal measure.
At its core, the book aims to empower women with ADHD, helping them embrace their unique traits while providing practical tools to manage daily challenges. Otsuka writes in an engaging, conversational style that often feels like a chat with a well-meaning friend. She shares personal stories and experiences that shine a light on the often-overlooked realities of women with ADHD. However, I couldn’t shake the feeling that her anecdotes catered to a demographic quite different from mine—those "Lean In" women who fit neatly into successful roles and experiences.
The writing style is breezy and filled with anecdotal insights, which can be comforting. Yet, as I delved deeper, it became clear that the structure often revolved back on her own solutions—like using AI to generate outlines or relying on standard neurotypical approaches for sleep and exercise. This raised questions in my mind. Did she rely too heavily on summaries, missing critical nuances that an AI could overlook? The repetitive nature of some chapters on exercise and sleep felt like a missed opportunity; I found myself yearning for deeper, more tailored insights that genuinely addressed the ADHD experience rather than glossing over it with overly general advice.
A notable moment was her discussion on rejection-sensitive dysphoria (RSD), which I believe many readers, particularly women, could find validating. However, the lighter tone sometimes tiptoed into dangerous territory—particularly with her attitude toward medication. Otsuka’s stance on how "exercise is the best ADHD treatment" felt dismissive of the complexities and sometimes harsh realities many face with this condition. The notion of viewing ADHD solely as a "superpower" felt overly optimistic and, at times, akin to toxic positivity.
Despite its shortcomings, the book’s positive affirmations and suggestions for self-discovery could be deeply empowering for women early in their ADHD journey. Otsuka’s anecdotes might resonate powerfully with those who have seldom heard experiences reflective of their own, bringing solace in feeling less isolated. Yet, her heavy reliance on personal anecdotes and self-promotion—peppering references to her Facebook groups and seminars—left me feeling as though I was reading more of a marketing pitch than a transformative guide.
Ultimately, ADHD for Smart Ass Women finds its strength in its anecdotal approach and relatable charm, though it often stumbles with a focus that seemed too narrow. While I appreciate the efforts to shed light on ADHD in women, I couldn’t help but wish for deeper insights and a more diverse representation of experiences. This book might serve as a buoy for those venturing into the world of ADHD awareness, particularly for high-achieving women navigating similar journeys. However, for readers like me—seeking depth and recognition of the multifaceted challenges within ADHD—it might feel more like a glossy introduction than an insightful exploration.
In sum, if you’re starting your ADHD journey and yearning for a light-hearted ally in a seemingly trivial world, this book may indeed serve that purpose. Just be prepared to sift through some fluff along the way.
Discover more about ADHD for Smart Ass Women: How to Fall in Love with Your… on GoodReads >>