Cozy Cosmic Whodunit: A Review of Murder by Memory by Olivia Waite
There’s something undeniably captivating about a locked-room mystery, especially when the "room" isn’t a room at all but rather a vibrant spaceship inhabited by 10,000 souls. When I stumbled upon Murder by Memory by Olivia Waite, I felt a combination of intrigue and skepticism; after all, how could a cozy murder mystery aboard a vessel in outer space possibly meet my expectations? Yet, here I am, delightfully astounded, ready to share why this book was such a delightful surprise!
From the first pages, Waite immerses us in the cozy environment of the HMS Fairweather, a ship that feels anything but cold and detached. The contrasting ideas of outer space and a “cozy” vibe go hand-in-hand like tea and biscuits. Instead of an austere Ai-driven existence, we are treated to lush, vivid descriptions of its bars, libraries, and even yarn stores. I found myself picturing vibrant community gatherings where custodial staff are heralded as heroes, and wealth disparity is non-existent. Who wouldn’t want to live in such a utopian setting? The prospect had me wishing not just to visit, but to establish roots among the ship’s community.
One of the standout concepts is the extraordinary idea of memories existing beyond our physical selves. The technology that allows characters to download their memories into tangible books is fascinating. Just imagine sipping a “Snowy Day” cocktail that evokes the freshness of winter while reliving some cherished memory! Waite’s exploration of identity—how our memories craft who we are—adds depth to the narrative, inviting readers to ponder profound questions while engrossed in a delightful mystery.
Now, let’s talk about the heart of the story: the murder itself. Waite skillfully crafts a plot where every layer intertwines, eliminating those frustrating moments when coercion seems evident. The crime is not just a random event, and as the story unfolds, it’s impressive how logically everything links together. My inner detective was completely satisfied with the conclusion, which tied up all loose ends without a trace of perfunctory “ah-ha” twists.
And what about Dorothy, our sharp, elderly sleuth? I adored her; she brings an unexpected perspective to the investigation. Seeing the world through her lens—filled with awe at unexpected vibrancies and sensations—imparts a warmth rarely found in cozy mysteries. It’s a joy to accompany her as she balances her newfound youth with her seasoned wisdom, avoiding the pitfalls of cynicism that often plague older characters.
While the ship’s cheeky AI added a bit of flair, it sometimes felt a pinch too whimsical for my taste. However, this minor quibble barely detracted from my enjoyment of a world so richly realized.
Murder by Memory is more than just a cozy mystery; it’s a nuanced exploration of identity, community, and the essence of who we truly are. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend this delightful read to fans of whimsical fantasy and thought-provoking science fiction alike, including those who have enjoyed Howl’s Moving Castle or the works of Mary Robinette Kowal and Travis Baldree.
In closing, if you’re in the mood for a delightful blend of mystery and cozy vibes in a captivating utopian setting, this book might just find its way into your heart as it did mine. I’m left with a longing to revisit the Fairweather and its loveable residents—I suppose that makes me a fan of Waite’s enchanting cosmos!
Discover more about Murder by Memory (Dorothy Gentleman, #1) on GoodReads >>