Review: Women Don’t Owe You Pretty by Florence Given
When I first came across Women Don’t Owe You Pretty, I was immediately drawn in by its bold title and promise of feminist empowerment. Florence Given, a young voice in the contemporary feminist discourse, seemed to hold the potential for a fresh take on themes that resonate with many of us. As I dove in, I found myself reflecting on my own journey as a woman in her thirties, and while there were certainly moments of recognition, I couldn’t help but feel a sense of déjà vu—a feeling that what was once thrilling had become, well, rather familiar.
The book tackles various themes: self-love, societal expectations of femininity, and the unbidden pressure to conform to traditional ideals of beauty and relationship. Given passionately advocates for a life defined on your own terms, and I found myself nodding in agreement. However, I also felt a noticeable absence of new insights. Many of the feminist ideas offered were those I’d encountered before, often articulated with more depth and nuance by previous authors. Phrases like “you don’t owe anyone your kindness” ring true, yet they felt a bit like echoes in a well-rehearsed mantra of feminism rather than groundbreaking revelations.
Florence Given’s writing style is conversational and accessible. At times, it felt like a fierce pep talk from a friend—as if she were standing right there, urging you to dismantle antiquated notions of womanhood. But along with the encouragement came a tone that occasionally felt aggressive, almost demanding in its decree. “Don’t get married! Don’t desire a partner!” her words practically shouted. While I wholeheartedly agree with the idea that women should never feel obligated to seek validation through marriage, the prescriptive nature of some of her advice felt a tad heavy-handed. Life, after all, is so much more nuanced than a checklist of demands.
One of the most striking aspects of the book is Given’s challenge to societal norms—calling out the contradictions and pressures women face is important, yet there’s a fine line between challenging those norms and inadvertently shaming individuals for their choices. It’s in this balance that I found my own conflict. While I believe firmly in accountability, the suggestions to cut people out of your life at the slightest mistake felt extreme. Mistakes are part of our human experience and an essential component of growth.
Women Don’t Owe You Pretty may not offer a plethora of groundbreaking insights, but it undeniably engages in the ongoing conversation about feminism and self-empowerment. Given’s calls to action resonate with a younger crowd still grappling with the pressures of modern life. However, for readers who’ve traversed similar discourses, the repetitiveness and occasionally contradictory tone may hinder deep engagement.
In conclusion, I believe this book may find its audience among younger women, those still navigating the turbulent waters of societal expectations and self-discovery. While I appreciated Given’s passion and the validation of familiar struggles, I found myself wishing for a more nuanced exploration. It’s a thoughtful read that serves as a reminder of the importance of dialogue in feminism, but be prepared for perspectives that may feel less like revelations and more like reaffirmation of what you may have learned long ago. If nothing else, it sparked reflection on my own beliefs and choices, and for that, I can appreciate its place on the shining shelf of contemporary feminist literature.
Discover more about Women Don’t Owe You Pretty on GoodReads >>