Book Review: A Letter from the Lonesome Shore (The Sunken Archive #2)
When I first plunged into A Letter from the Lonesome Shore, I was riding high on the submerged enchantment of its predecessor, A Letter to the Luminous Deep. The allure of an underwater world intertwined with academia and fantasy beckoned me, promising an adventure ripe with discovery and mystery—that is, until I arrived at the proverbial depths that left me gasping for a breath of inspiration.
In this sequel, reuniting with characters E and Henerey as they navigate a new society captivated by knowledge was an exciting prospect. The stakes rise as Sophy and Vyerin search desperately for their siblings while an ancient threat looms in the shadows—a plot thread rich with potential. Yet, despite the tantalizing setup, I found myself floundering amid the execution.
The epistolary style, which had enchanted me in the first book, felt forced this time around. Instead of personal letters that slipped into the characters’ voices, we encounter a patchwork of unsent messages, journal entries, and official reports laden with back-and-forth dialogues that grew monotonous. This not only dulled the emotional edge but blurred character distinctions, making it challenging to engage deeply with their struggles.
While the prologue efficiently recapped the essentials, I found the pacing just disheartening. So much time dedicated to groundwork rather than moving the plot forward left me feeling not just stagnant, but frustrated. An unexpected infodump around the 70% mark added to my weariness—details that could have added intrigue were instead piled on like heavy stones, overshadowing the tensions built throughout the narrative.
Yet, amid this sea of disappointments, there were bright spots. The nuanced portrayal of anxiety and mental health issues was refreshingly authentic, and the LGBTQ+ representation remains commendable. The cover art, an ethereal beauty, mirrors the stunning visual potential of the narrative world, and glimpses of a new society’s relationship with knowledge offered intriguing insights. Unfortunately, these moments fell short of elevating the overall experience.
As I closed this nearly 800-page tome, I was left pondering the expected revelations. Despite the amalgamation of mythology and creature lore that fascinated me, the grand finale slipped by without the anticipated tension. For a book promising depth, it ultimately felt brief and lacked resonance.
For readers who adored the first installment and yearn for closure regarding E and Henerey, this book might still offer some semblance of conclusion. But for those seeking a standalone adventure akin to Emily Wilde—a comparison I found wholly misplaced—it’s wise to approach with tempered expectations.
Ultimately, while A Letter from the Lonesome Shore had the makings of a captivating journey, it became a case of “Wow Concept, Average Execution.” I must sadly dock my rating at 2 stars, rooting for future storytelling endeavors to dive deeper and embrace the treasures just beneath the surface.
Thank you to Little, Brown Book Group UK and Orbit for the DRC via NetGalley. May the next installment bring forth the vivid narratives we crave!
Discover more about A Letter from the Lonesome Shore (The Sunken Archive, #… on GoodReads >>